Another recommendation from our trusty Tribeca connoisseur!
We went here to celebrate my 40th b-day a few years ago and have been back many times. I love the atmosphere and the Angry Lobster, the house specialty. From the old school decor, to the upstairs jazz room, start to finish, this is a place to try. Wonderful food, portions are hearty and service is top notch. We live in Tribeca and I've since brought several people here and everyone is always in agreement; you want old NYC? Come here!